Thursday, April 12, 2012

Randy Alcorn's Book Heaven Reviewed: The Not So Good

Dr. David R. ReaganPDFBy

In the first half of this book review of Randy Alcorn's book Heaven, I pointed out how well the author dispelled some misconceptions about Heaven. In this second half, I'll point out some doctrinal areas of contention I have with this book.

The thing that amazed me was how anyone could write 476 pages about Heaven when the Bible says so little about it. I discovered four keys to the author's in-depth coverage.

Heaven by Randy Alcorn


The first is the author's imagination. He can derive more hints from a verse than anyone I have ever encountered. A good example can be found on pages 65-67 where he derives 21 conclusions from Revelation 6:9-11. That's a total of three verses! Many of these conclusions, though not unbiblical, are nonetheless quite a stretch and need to be recognized as such.


The second key to the author's in-depth writing on a topic so scantily covered by Scripture is that he misapplies many passages about the Millennium to the Eternal State. For example, every time the Scriptures mention "new heavens and a new earth," as in Isaiah 65:17, he immediately jumps to the conclusion that the passage pertains to the Eternal State. But this is not always the case, and it certainly is not in the Isaiah 65 passage where death and child bearing are both mentioned.

The fact the author seems to overlook is that there are two new earths that lie ahead of us. One is the Millennial earth which will be this earth radically changed by earthquakes and supernatural phenomena in the heavens. The second will be the eternal earth which will be the Millennial earth renovated by fire.

Common Sense

The third factor that has enabled Mr. Alcorn to write in such depth is what I would characterize as his extraordinary common sense. Many of his conclusions are derived from what I would call common sense reasoning. For example, in dealing with the often asked question, "Will I maintain my identity in Heaven?" Mr. Alcorn writes (page 278):

You will be you in Heaven. Who else would you be? If Bob, a man on earth, is no longer Bob when he goes to Heaven, then, in fact, Bob did not go to Heaven. If when I arrive in Heaven, I'm not the same person with the same identity, history, and memory, then I didn't go to Heaven.


The fourth and most important factor that has produced Mr. Alcorn's in-depth thinking about Heaven is what he calls "the principle of redemptive continuity." By this he means that eternal life will be as life is now — except that it will be perfected. So, if you want to imagine what Heaven will be like, look around you and imagine what this world would be like without disease, suffering, crime, and natural calamities. Here's how Mr. Alcorn puts it (page 112):

Conversion does not mean eliminating the old but transforming it. Despite the radical changes that occur through salvation, death, and resurrection, we remain who we are. We have the same history, appearance, memory, interests, and skills. This is the principle of redemptive continuity. God will not scrap His original creation and start over. Instead, He will take His fallen, corrupted children and restore, refresh, and renew us to our original design.

Applying this principle to the Eternal State, Mr. Alcorn titles one of his chapters, "What will our daily lives be like?" (pages 317-324). He asks: "Will we rest? Will we sleep? Will we work? Will we have our own homes? Will we open our homes to guests?"

To all these questions he applies the principle of redemptive continuity and concludes by answering them with a resounding "Yes!"

Exceptions to Continuity

He does, however, point out that there will be some exceptions to the principle of continuity. One of the most important being marriage and sex. The only marriage that will exist in Heaven will be that of the Redeemed to the Lord Jesus Christ. Jesus made it clear in Matthew 22:30 that in our glorified, immortal bodies we will not marry.

Mr. Alcorn reasons that since there will be no marriage in Heaven as we know it today, there will also be no sex, since it was designed by God to be a part of the marriage relationship. But he speculates that it may be replaced by something even better (page 338):

There may... be some way in which the intimacy and pleasure we now know as sex will be fulfilled in some higher form. I don't know what that would be, but I do know that sex was designed by God, and I don't expect Him to discard it without replacing it with something better.

Another Disappointing Feature

In addition to his misapplication of some Millennial passages to the Eternal State, there is one other thing I found disappointing about Mr. Alcorn's book. It was his ambivalence about the Millennium. He states point-blank that he believes there will be a literal thousand year reign of Jesus on this present earth, but he hastens to add that he is not "dogmatic" about it because "I also understand and respect the strong interpretive arguments that have been made in support of Amillennialism" (page 140).

It is amazing to me that a man who demands that all scriptures about Heaven be taken literally would turn around and say he can understand why some people might want to spiritualize the passages concerning the Millennium. I suspect that this sentence was due to pressure from the publisher (Tyndale House) in order to give the book a wider appeal.

Nonetheless, I highly recommend the book. It is thorough, carefully reasoned, biblical, thought-provoking, and highly entertaining. Mr. Alcorn is obviously a person who has spent innumerable hours thinking about Heaven. Also, his fundamental thesis about the nature of Heaven is one that Christendom needs to hear because it is directly related to the strength and quality of our hope.

The Relationship of Prophecy to Hope

Many Christians, because they know so little about the world to come, cling tenaciously to this world, living with little hope. Mr. Alcorn's outstanding book will convince you that "the best is yet to come."

And that, in turn, reminds me of the story of the dying woman who told her pastor she wanted to be buried with a fork in her right hand. When he asked why, she said: "Every time we have a pot-luck meal at church, we are told to keep our forks when the plates are picked up, because, referring to the desserts, we are told, 'The best is yet to come!'"

Yes, the best is yet to come, and because of that Randy Alcorn ends his book with an interesting thought (page 415):

We have redefined eternal life to mean an off-Earth existence stripped of the defining properties of what we know life to be. Eternal life will be enjoying forever what life on Earth is at its finest moments, what it was intended to be. Since in Heaven we'll finally experience life at its best, it would be more accurate to call our present experience the beforelife rather than what follows the afterlife.

And all I can add to that is Maranatha!

Another Recommended Book on Heaven

Eternity: Heaven or Hell?Eternity: Heaven or Hell?
Item ID: P-16

What will happen when you die? This and many other questions about death and its aftermath are dealt with in this book, based upon biblical answers.

In addition, Dr. David Reagan deals with questions pertaining to salvation: Are there many roads to God? Can salvation be earned through good works? Can salvation be lost? He also takes an in-depth look at the resurrection of Jesus, examining the evidence for it and discussing its essentiality to the Christian faith.

197 pages.

Order your copy today!


Billy said...

Since I probably wouldn't like most of the speculation part of the book I'll avoid it.

As I said in another be honest, the thought of being Earthbound for eternity doesn't sound all that exciting, kinda like Dr. Reagan's view of being cloudbound with a harp.

I want to explore the universe and discover all the different worlds and galaxies out there...and have an eternity to do it!

Not that I don't want to have my "home" on Earth in the beautiful place Jesus is preparing for me but it would be fun, to my current limited mortal still in the flesh mind, to go out on discovery expeditions.

Susie said...

I firmly believe our eternal destiny is unfathomable and our home (new jerusalem) is but home base!!!!!!!!

ibamum said...

I think it is important that we have God's view on what eternity is; and, since there is little of it written in the Bible, it's best to be cautious about what we FIRMLY believe about the topic. God just might surprize us.

Daniel said...

I found Randy Alcorn's book to be entirely Biblical and a huge encouragement. I don't understand the negative review, but then the positive tag at the end. Please consider revising this review as you may sway many away from reading something that could offer them great encouragment into a Biblical topic that so few have studied in depth. Please be more gracious in your review...I feel like it fails to give appreciation to the amount of Biblical reference Alcorn uses to support his points in, "Heaven". I'm a very discerning reader and found the subject held up against close Scriptural examination.

Anonymous said...

Dr Reagan is less than enthusiastic about Alcorn's book and recommends a better, more accurate book...great! oh look, he wrote the book he's recommending! Hmmm.....

mar13 said...

Thanks for the review. I also appreciate your specific critical remarks on pages 65-67 as being too imaginative. So I get on to and do a preview of just those pages. I really like how observant the author was about the text, and I ended up buying the book. Just as you suggested at the end of the review :-)

Cindy said...

I have a friend that was given a diagnosis that makes us think of Heaven, This book has been encouraging to her in 2 ways, one for herself and another helping her deal with the death of her parents. As a follower of Jesus this book can be a blessing to those that are forced to look at Heaven in their near future and comforting when a loved one is there. Praying while reading such books by asking God to reveal truth with be an awesome blessing.

Pat Marvenko Smith said...

This book had a huge impact on me and my thinking on heaven. From the time I first read "Heaven" by Randy Alcorn a few years ago, I have been buying copies and giving them to people who are terminally ill or who have lost loved ones. It is so uplifting and eye-opening. We recently did a series of adult Sunday school classes with Randy's study based on this book. One wonderful Christian woman in our class got seriously ill when our series was almost finished. While she spent her last days in the hospital, she often rejoiced at how this study had prepared her for what she knew was coming and she was anxiously waiting to see the other side. Although there may be some disagreements with portions of the book, I think the main in depth message about heaven as a whole is so important that this book is a must read!

Tish said...

Having lost a son, husband and both parents I was so grateful when I found this book. I have found it to be uplifting, accurate and so very encouraging. Randy Alcorn has done his homework and has painstakingly stayed within scriptural boundaries. I am a GriefShare facilitator and always recommend this book when we study our session on HEAVEN. It has been a blessing to me and hundreds who have gone searching for answers in their grief. Grief does, indeed, teach you what you believe about God. Thank you, Randy, for so reverently sharing scripture so humbly and accurately!

Mercado said...

Me too!